But the guy forgot one critical piece of logic: the people who build fences know exactly how to tear them down. Fed up with being harassed, the foreman walked to his truck, grabbed a sledgehammer and began to systematically take down what they just put up. It’s a basic economic transaction: You work, you get paid. You break the deal, you lose the fence. But leave it up to Jesus to completely ruin our clean, comfortable math. And mess with our idea of fairness. He lays it all out in this parable: ‘For the kingdom of heaven is like a landowner who went out early in the morning to hire labourers for his vineyard. After agreeing with the labourers for the usual daily wage, he sent them into his vineyard. When he went out about nine o’clock, he saw others standing idle in the market-place; and he said to them, “You also go into the vineyard, and I will pay you whatever is right.” So they went. When he went out again about noon and about three o’clock, he did the same. And about five o’clock he went out and found others standing around; and he said to them, “Why are you standing here idle all day?” They said to him, “Because no one has hired us.” He said to them, “You also go into the vineyard.” It’s safe to say, Jesus isn’t that concerned about the ethics of business or labor management relations. But as this story makes it clear, he is concerned about fairness. Especially the kind that contradicts our notion of it. The idea that you get what you deserve. Merriam-Webster defines fairness as treating people equally, honestly, and without bias or favoritism. But if you grew up with siblings, you know that definition falls apart pretty fast. I’m the youngest of four kids. None of us doubted that our parents loved us equally. But my siblings would say we weren’t all treated equally. They still insist I got away with murder. As a parent now, I see what they mean. Our firstborn, got all our attention, good and bad. She had to carry the weight of all our initial expectations. Our second got more leeway in comparison. Colleen benefitted from what we learned with Fiona. By the time Sean came along, we’d thrown in the towel. And I’ll admit, as the youngest, he gets away with murder. His siblings, like mine, still rightfully declare, "It’s not fair!" And they’re right. It’s not. Life isn’t fair, and that’s Jesus’ point in this parable. True fairness isn't just about giving everyone the exact same slice of the pie. It’s about equity—meeting people where they are and give them what they need based on their unique circumstances. And that seems, well, unfair. Right? Yet, I’m sure we all agree all things are not equal. Some of us are born with safety nets; others are born into survival. Jesus knows how the world operates. Which is precisely why he keeps reminding us the kingdom of heaven doesn't run like Wall Street. In this parable, a vineyard owner has had a tremendous year. His crop is so bountiful that it’s too much work for the regular crew to handle. He sends out his manager to hire day laborers, a practice that’s still common today. He hires the first group at six in the morning, agreeing to pay them the standard daily wage of one denarius. Yet, there is still more work. So, he goes back out at nine in the morning, then at noon, again at three, and finally at five o’clock, right before the sun sets. And with each group he hires, he negotiates the same wage…one denarius. When payday comes, the manager lines everyone up. He pays the last guys first; handing them a denarius for a single hour of work. The ones who were hired first see this and start doing math in their heads. They assume if one hour of work gets that, then their twelve hours of sweating under the blazing sun must be worth a lot more. But when it’s their time to get paid, the manager hands them the exact same wage. They immediately start complaining, how those who barely broke a sweat were made equal to those who bore the burden of the scorching heat. “It’s not fair!” Then there’s Jesus, smiling at their outrage, saying, "Yes! Exactly!" That’s his point: God is unfair. Why? Because we are unfair to one another. God’s economy isn’t built on our definitions of equity. It’s built on love and grace, which means it has to be unfair in the best way possible. Nadia Bolz-Weber calls, God’s grace “A scandalous thing. It doesn’t follow the rules of supply and demand. It is poured out lavishly, recklessly, on the worthy and the unworthy alike.” You see, to God, fairness isn’t about giving everyone the same thing. It’s about giving everyone what they need. The early workers got the amount they agreed to, and the latecomers got the same. Everyone made a deal and was content until they saw what everyone else received. I’m sure we’d all like to think of ourselves as the generous landowner. Or perhaps we’d like to be the one’s hired last. But if we’re being honest, we’re probably more like the one’s complaining. Our gut resists this outcome because we live in a world where reward is strictly tied to performance. Here, Jesus turns that model upside down. And in the process, he reveals something beautiful about God. As Brennan Manning notes, “God loves us as we are, not as we should be, because nobody is as they should be.” Yet so many of us buy into the lie that grace must be earned. Like God is some sort of store where you can buy redemption. This lie secretly convinces us that, “I’m not worthy of God’s grace.” And then, ironically, we project that shame and burden onto others believing we deserve God's favor more. Either grace is for everyone, or the gospel isn't real. God doesn’t leave anyone outside the vineyard. Theologian Justo González invites us to see this parable through the eyes of the day laborers standing in the parking lot of Home Depot. They aren’t looking for a handout, but a hand up. They risk deportation, for an honest days work so their kids can eat tonight. Imagine the shame they feel after standing in the heat all day getting passed over, like the last workers hired in Jesus’ parable, knowing they might go home empty-handed. When the manager sees them still standing around waiting for work, he doesn't see lazy people. He sees desperate fathers. He offers them a full days wage—not because they produced twelve hours of work, but because their families need to survive the night. Whether you’ve been faithful all your life or turned to God five minutes ago, God’s merciful grace is the same for all. If you want it, just ask for it and it’s yours. Because God dispenses gifts, not wages. In our world, that’s not fair. And God knows it. While human unfairness exploits, God's unfairness restores. When our notion of fairness leaves others out, God welcomes them in. The real danger for us today isn't missing out on grace. It's becoming the bitter worker staring resentfully at everyone else's paycheck. The moment we measure our neighbor's wage instead of God’s generosity, Jesus exposes our heart. The vineyard owner asks, "Are you envious because I am generous?" Think about how you would answer that question to God. Jesus’ parable reminds me of something that happened centuries earlier, when the prophet Jonah threw the exact same fit outside Nineveh. He was furious that God showed mercy to “those people” folks who found redemption at the last minute. Jonah admits that God is "generous and loving" to a fault. But he’s angry that God would be that way with someone he believed didn’t deserve it. Imagine being angry at God’s goodness. Yet whenever we fight against giving equity to others, we aren't defending fairness—we’re denying God’s goodness. Right now, political leaders are threatening schools and companies that implement Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion initiatives. Their outrage over DEI is fueled by the exact same instinct as those first-hour workers screaming, "It’s not fair! You’re giving special treatment to people who didn't earn it!" And so, in the name of "fairness," these politicians construct legal and economic barriers to make sure those who started ten paces behind stay ten paces behind. But here’s the thing: when society tries to outlaw equity, it’s actively delegitimizing God’s glory. Denying and even destroying all the goodness and hope that God brings into the world through Christ Jesus. Because DEI is simply trying to do in our broken world what the Vineyard Owner did in his field. It finds those who historically have been passed over and says, "You belong here. Your family deserves to eat too." When we obsess over protecting our privilege, we become just like that homeowner withholding payment for his fence. We think we can use our power to exploit workers and threatening anyone who asks for a fair share. Jesus reminds us that God’s grace isn’t a column on a spreadsheet or a balance to be calculated. We don't have to spend our lives bitterly counting the coins in other people's hands, or demanding sledgehammers to smash down every structure built to help our neighbor catch up. Instead, we can follow the way of Jesus by stepping outside our gated yards, tearing down our fences, and resting in the scandalous reality that God’s grace is wildly, wonderfully, and endlessly unfair. And thank God for that. Because if God were actually fair, none of us would stand a chance.
1 Comment
Susan Dukow
9/20/2026 04:02:36 pm
Thank you, my friend. You never cease to amaze and delight me.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
Ian MacdonaldAn ex-copywriter turned punk rock pastor and peacemaker who dedicates his life to making the world a better place for all humanity. "that they all might be one" ~John 17:21Get the Book“Prius vita quam doctrina.”
~ St. Thomas Aquinas (1225–1274) * “Life is more important than doctrine.”
|